Saturday, May 03, 2008

Optimism, Pessimism and calling something 'Art'

I don't complain about something that works on an entirely different level of abstraction and symbolism - like David Lynch's "Eraserhead" - but those movies which try to come to notice by adding a tone of pessimism to the scripts - something like "Lilja 4ever". Trying to force you to accept that 'life is like that' or making it difficult just so that it doesn't get obvious. Things ending, people dying just because they weren't supposed to in commercial cinema. And no, its not a depiction of reality or documenting things as they are. Its just a sad play at things to qualify as having a vision.

Optimisim is inherent to us. We used to, and forever will continue to wish well for the one we identify with on the screen - one among the protagonists or the innocent third person that never had to do anything with the kerfuffle anyways.
A long drive on any sort of road is a realisation in our optimist tendencies. The concern for the scores of birds or animals that you find idling in the middle of your road is a confirmation. Birds, especially, play on that dramatic urge inside us that wants to see survival of any species. They'll just sit there, oblivious to your approach. You grow impatient, more so if a passenger. You feel like you're going to reduce something to pulp in a short while - the feeling grows as you get closer. Closer. Now the bonnet shields the birds from your sight. Yours legs stiffen, heart skips a beat, as you wait for a low thud. But nothing. You pass by the spot, to find the birds safely fluttering away on either side of the road. Seinfeld put it right - we have a pact with them!

One sad incident I recall has relation to this. Was 10 years back, when driving from Lucknow to Gethia with family. When our car ran over a squirrel. The poor thing was in the middle of the road, and sensed our approaching vehicle a little too late. It would've been fine if it had either done that earlier, or been completely oblivious to it. But a late judgement made it run for the trees right when our car passed by. A gentle crunch of the bones. Pulp. The crunch was inversely loud in volumes inside me, as I still remember it.

So screw you, rubbish 'art' movies. Everytime I come across one of you, I think of the squirrel and wish that it would've lived. I wish Lilja would've lived.

No comments: